Choose a city:
Buffalo
Cleveland
Columbus
Los Angeles
New York
Pennsylvania
Pittsburgh
More Cities...
Urbanspoon Pittsburgh
Add a photo from this restaurant
Get our newsletter
Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to get the scoop on Pittsburgh restaurants.
| Is this your restaurant? |
Menu for 17th Street Cafe
Italian, American and Desserts/Ice Cream
$10-15 per entree
Special Features: Gluten-Free Friendly, Vegan Friendly and Romantic
Get Urbanspoon on your 
Critic reviews for 17th Street Cafe
|
City Paper
A quaint restaurant located in the heart of historic South Side, The 17th Street Cafe specializing in all types of cuisi full review | all City Paper reviews |
|
Pittsburgh Magazine
full review |
|
Pittsburgh Post Gazette
full review |
Blog posts on 17th Street Cafe
 |
FoodBurgh
November 12, 2009 - Anytime I’m in the vicinity of the Southside I feel this super natural pull to Fatheads for their ridiculous beer... full post | all FoodBurgh reviews |
 |
Sweet-Cakes and Milkshakes
Likes it August 17, 2009 - This restaurant is run flawlessly. full post | all Sweet-Cakes and Milkshakes reviews |
User reviews of 17th Street Cafe
Share your opinion with the world. Add your review below.
|
"High expectations..."
by RCase
(12 reviews)
November 26, 2009 - Likes it - I had pretty high expectations for this place, based on recommendations from friends and reviews on this site. Upon being seated, I initially wasn't impressed with the size of the place and the wait staff. While the appetizer (fried zucchini) was very good, I thought the salad was a bit disappointing. The house salad dressing (a balsamic vinegarette) was quite average - even though they sell it by the bottle. But my overall expectations were met - and then some - by the entrees we had. Their unique preparations made for very tasty dishes. The portions were more than adequate. This is what I expect from a local eatery trying to distinguish itself. |
|
"Awesome little restaurant"
by Samara
(42 reviews)
November 24, 2009 - Likes it - This cafe is where we go for special occassions, we've gone at least 4 times to this quaint little cafe tucked away in the South Side. Good food, a little bit expensive but worth it! |
|
|
"One of our all time favorites"
by ftf113ftw
(7 reviews)
September 15, 2009 - Likes it - The 17th street cafe was one of our favorite places to dine before our daughter was born. It is cozy and the staff are very friendly. The food absolutley rocks! One of my personal favorites then was the twin filets in hunters sauce. It was out of this world. |
|
 mobile review
by Megan McNeish
(1 review)
September 03, 2009 - Doesn't like it - Just returned from dinner and it was awful. 4 of us went each having something different...no one liked their meal. It is way over priced too. We will not be going back. |
|
mobile review
by Matthew Kulikowski
(2 reviews)
July 28, 2009 - Likes it - Great food, prepared fresh daily. Pat is a wizard in the kitchen! |
|
|
"Hideaway"
by Grubby Ape
(7 reviews)
June 01, 2009 - Likes it - Just off of Carson, it's small and personable. t's the perfect date night place and it's always a surprise for people that haven't seen it before. It has a Valet service just next to Nakama, so you don't have to struggle for parking. The service is outstanding and the menu is varied for everyone. 1 person likes this review Recommend |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
mobile review
by ktk 32
(3 reviews)
February 04, 2009 - Likes it - "Save it for Date Night" Such a romantic little restaurant and very personal with the waitstaff and chef very interested in making your dining experience special! The food is devine and it's wonderful to share it with your special someone! 1 person likes this review Recommend |
|
|
"perfect-my favorite place"
by rmm22
(1 review)
November 02, 2008 - I have been dining at 17th St. Cafe for a long time and must say it always remains to have fantastic food. The atmosphere (romantic, cozy, friendly) and staff - not to mention the owner- are all fantastic. I just can't wait to return. This truly is my "comfort" restaurant. It is perfect in every way - food, drink, atmosphere,staff and the owner who always comes by your table for a little conversation to see how you liked it. 1 person likes this review Recommend |
|
|
"Consistently good"
by JB
(1 review)
August 27, 2008 - Likes it - The 17th Street Cafe has appeal for all ages. My parents, my teenage children, and my husband and I all love it. Their ingredients for success......consistently fresh and deliciously prepared food, attentive service, relaxed and friendly atmosphere. 3 people like this review Recommend |
|
|
"Southside Favorite"
by sansbranches
(1 review)
August 21, 2008 - Likes it - I have been to the cafe a dozen times over the last few years and every time I've enjoyed my food, and from the plates of my co-diners. The atmosphere is asthetically pleasing without being overly genuine or kitch. I am always impressed with the level of execution in the pairing of flavors & the quality of the product. My server Chatty Kathy is adept at serving without being fakey or long-winded, and I've enjoyed her service every time she has been my server. She also doesn't rattle off the descriptions in such a way that I can tell she's never actually eaten the food, or have some arbitrary favorite depending on what is ordered. I should mention that being genuine on my part at such length has a lot to do with the fact that I am a cook/server by trade, and finding a successful restaurant to go to is something I particularly enjoy, and it is a ten minute walk from my house. 1 person likes this review Recommend |
|
|
"I can't wait to go back again"
by BookNona
(2 reviews)
August 20, 2008 - Likes it - Last week my friend and I had dinner at 17th St Cafe. I had the Sausage and Pepper Ravioli, which was great. My friend had the Pasta Serrenti, which was one of the most fabulous dishes I have EVER tasted! The blend of flavors was wonderfully complex, but not overwhelming. In addition to the fantastic food, the friendliness and attention of the staff and the owner was, as usual, what really made the dining experience most enjoyable! Keep up the good work, folks! 1 person likes this review Recommend |
|
|
|
|
|
"Irish"
by irish
(1 review)
August 18, 2008 - Likes it - We were on the Southside to go to the City Theatre and planned on having dinner some where on Carson St. As we were parking our car we ran into a friend and asked him for a recommendation. He told us about the 17th. St. Cafe. Boy do we owe him big time. We had a wonderful dinner. The food was fantastic. I had the London Broil special which was cut so well and was so tender. My friend had the New York Strip with a sherry butter sauce that was to die for. We were treated so well by Pat the owner and ALL of the Wait staff you would have thought we were long lost friends. We our so HAPPY we found the 17th St. Cafe and we can't wait to go back. 1 person likes this review Recommend |
|
|
"Great food & Good times"
by drader
(1 review)
August 16, 2008 - Likes it - When my husband and I visit his family in Pittsburgh, we always make a special request to visit 17th Street cafe. We love everything so much-from the speciality drinks at the bar to the appetizers, salads, soups, entrees, and desserts. We have never been disappointed on the service or the food. The atmosphere is very comfy and the staff is there for their customers. It's one of the few places you can get everything in one place. The fried zucchini and red pepper soup are amazing! 1 person likes this review Recommend |
|
|
"Local couple and Monroe, MI guests"
by fredvalentino2003
(1 review)
August 15, 2008 - Brought out of town guests to the 17th Street Cafe and they loved the sausage ravioli and the London Broil steak. That night they also had a pineapple upside down martini that was unusual and tasty. My wife had three. We have been there for lunch and dinner several times and been impressed with the menu and the staff. Great place!!! |
|
|
"All postings are honest."
by southsidepat
(4 reviews)
August 15, 2008 - Really likes it - My name is Pat Joyce the owner of 17th Street cafe and I have recently discover Urban Spoon and have simply asked my guest to go and let others know why they eat at 17th Street Cafe. All postings are honest. Come on down and find out for yourself. |
|
"Fake Reviews????"
by Troy
(149 reviews)
August 14, 2008 - - Is it just me, or does it seem like the 17th Street Cafe is trying to toot their own horn by writing up and posting a bunch of good reviews???? All those posts are by folks with only one review to their name, and almost all are posted on the same day (they post 3 per day it seems). It just looks suspicious (and dishonest) to me!!!Anybody REAL actually eat there??? 4 people like this review Recommend |
|
|
"We loved this place!!"
by Nancy
(1 review)
August 13, 2008 - Likes it - My girlfriend took me here for my birthday celebration ...what a great place! It's cozy and inviting with agreat wait staff. The food was delicious and creatively prepared. The sliced turkey and roasted asparagus sandwich is worth a return trip! I'd definitely recommend eating here! |
|
|
"Mmmm Good"
by ECHILD12
(1 review)
August 13, 2008 - Likes it - I've been a fan since the day it opened. Living across the street does have it's perks. I would rather spend a couple of extra bucks and order quality, than walk only a block to save a buck and eat a less than special meal that barely fills me! 17th Street food Rocks and the staff is the BEST in the South Side! |
|
|
"Big TASTE in a small place"
by Denver-Man
(3 reviews)
August 13, 2008 - Likes it - Wow! We found a GEM of restaurant in the South Side of PIttsburgh! This small place is full of BIG taste. I absolutely LOVED the stuffed banana peppers.We were greeted by the owner upon on arrival and he made sure that we had everything we needed throughout the evening. I highly recommend that anyone who has not visited the 17th Street Cafe do so...go early because this small restaurant fills up fast! |
|
|
"Secret Hideaway!"
by linda
(1 review)
August 12, 2008 - Likes it - I was lucky to find the 17th Street Cafe - just steps away from the crazy commercial road - what a quaint lovely little place. The service is very friendly. food was also very good - the portions are generous. The history of 17th Street Cafe is also interesting. There seems to be such a regular clientele - it's like visiting friends. Next time I'm in Pittsburgh I'll definitely go back! |
|
|
"Passa da Pasta again!!!"
by mackcon
(1 review)
August 12, 2008 - Likes it - I just want to say how tender and delicious the pasta is at this place.Mama mia I cannot wait to go to this cozy gem again and again.The food, the sevice and the ambiance is delightful and will be recommending it to all my friends. Try it. |
|
|
|
|
|
"Outstanding"
by chowdahman
(3 reviews)
August 11, 2008 - Likes it - My wife and I recently visited Pittsburgh for the first time, we were fortunate to stumble on the 17th St. Cafe and what a treat it turned out to be. Growing up in Boston, we had a number of these hidden gems in obscure neighborhoods. The 17th street cafe is a unique combination of great food, atmosphere and service. The moment you walk thru the door, you know you're in for a special evening. The menu is diverse, with a number of Italian specialties all presented with an emphasis on quality. You know you've had a great experience when after the meal, you retire to the bar for an after dinner drink. You don't want your evening to end. I would highly recommend a visit to the 17th Street Cafe, I know I'll make a special trip to Pittsburgh for a return visit. |
|
|
"simply put, a gem in the Southside"
by Monica
(1 review)
August 10, 2008 - Likes it - I brought a friend to 17th Street Cafe recently because I liked it so much the first time. The owner, Pat, is an extremely likeable fellow and treated us as 'old friends'. He and his servers went out of their way to provide us with a terrific meal and a memorable experience. The restaurant is fun, charming and relaxed and of course the abundant food was delicious. Favorites were the asparagus and turkey sandwich, the chicken dish with eggplant and buffalo mozzarella, the canoli and tiramisu. You must try the 17th Street cosmo! |
|
|
"The absolute best!!"
by Dawn Morse
(1 review)
August 08, 2008 - Likes it - This quaint and cozy restaurant has the charm and warmth like no other. The owners go out of their way to make you feel at home. The banana peppers and zuchinni were to die for. I highly recommend a trip into the southside of Pittsburgh to try this restaurant because you won't be disappointed! |
|
|
|
|
"If Cheers served great food"
by cookinguy
(1 review)
August 07, 2008 - Likes it - This is the kind of neighborhood joint that makes me wish this was my neighborhood. Four of us went there four lunch the other day and all of us wanted what the other people ordered. Don't miss the Reuben "Sandwich" that uses potato pancakes instead of bread. It is truly inspired. |
|
|
"hip comfort"
by Craig
(1 review)
August 07, 2008 - Likes it - We love places like this (but they are hard to find) as soon as you walk in, the first thing to hit you in this cozy cafe it that it has real personality. The owner greeted us (a rare occurrence at other restaurants) and the servers made us feel like old friends. But the proof is in the pudding - or should I say the chicken. Our meal was great, from the best salad dressing I have ever found to the grilled chicken with grilled eggplant and tomato. Don't let the "Cafe" in the name deceive you this is a hip little bistro.Food ***Service ***Environment ***This is the only place I have found that can do all three with out paying our typical over $100 a couple. |
|
|
"Amazing!"
by Fun Researcher
(4 reviews)
August 07, 2008 - Likes it - I am a restaurant photographer from Vancouver Canada. I travel to restaurants all over North America and I have to say that the 17th street Cafe is in my top five favorite restaurants for the price range. Inexpensive gourmet food is rare and this place kicks ass. The stuffed banana peppers are my absolute favorite - the last time I was through I went there four days in a row. See Pat the owner...great guy and great staff. It is small and not too many seats but definitely worth the wait. 1 person likes this review Recommend |
Fans of 17th Street Cafe
People who like this restaurant, and how many others they like.
124 others |
94 others |
74 others |
69 others |
65 others |
Is this your restaurant?
Add an Urbanspoon badge
to your web site.
Here's an example:
Nearby restaurants
See other nearby restaurants
See all South Side Italian Restaurants
Nearby places
People reached this page by searching for:
