Choose a city:   Buffalo    Cleveland    Columbus    Los Angeles    New York    Pennsylvania    Pittsburgh      More Cities...
Urbanspoon Pittsburgh

Add_photo Add a photo from this restaurant

See all 12 reviews

Get our newsletter

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to get the scoop on Pittsburgh restaurants. See details

Home > Pittsburgh > South > Waterfront >

Is this your restaurant?

Mitchell's Fish Market

(412) 476-8844

Waterfront
185 Waterfront Dr W
Homestead, PA 15120
www.mitchellsfishmarket.com

Send to phone

162 people have voted
V-up-big
76%
like it
Add your vote

Menu for Mitchell's Fish Market

 Get Urbanspoon on your iPhone or Blackberry

Critic reviews for Mitchell's Fish Market

143 Pittsburgh Post Gazette
May 18, 2006 - Dining Review: Pines Tavern, Mitchell's and La Casa offer the perfect garden spots  
full review | all Pittsburgh Post Gazette reviews
140 City Paper
Mitchell's Fish Market features a wide variety of fresh fish and seafood flown in daily. Reservations recommended on we  
full review | all City Paper reviews
141 Citysearch rated it 4.5/5.0
A nautical motif best describes this upscale restaurant's interior. Large dining areas range from quiet to bustling...  
full review | all Citysearch reviews

Bloggers, have you reviewed this restaurant? Add your review to this page.

User reviews of Mitchell's Fish Market

Share your opinion with the world. Add your review below.

photo
Phone mobile review by Chris Fry (51 reviews)
October 12, 2009 - Likes it - Yup. Mitchell's has that chain feel and environment. But the food was good, the fish was fresh and the drinks were mixed well. What else do you need before going to the movie? And the wait isn't as bad as at P.f. Chang's. :-)

Recommend this review

photo
Phone mobile review by Ken Rogers (1 review)
September 22, 2009 - Likes it - This resteraunt has good fish. I ate there one day and I noticed they have a wide verity of fish and seafood at a decent price. The food even has good taste as well. If you like seafood, then this is the place to go to.

Recommend this review

photo
Phone mobile review by Adison (15 reviews)
August 03, 2009 - Likes it - I also agree there are better sea food places but there is no doubt this one is still good!

Recommend this review

photo
Phone mobile review by Adison (15 reviews)
August 03, 2009 - Likes it - Great tuna melt and best dessert "Shark Fin Pie"! Overal one of my favorite restraunts!

Recommend this review

No_photo_small
"average food, average service" by Grubby Ape (7 reviews)
June 01, 2009 - Doesn't like it - The food is only average - there are many better seafood places in the city for the price. We had the Mussels for an appetizer and they were overcooked, and by a lot. I had the Hoisin Yellowfin for dinner and found it to be bland. My wife had the Pecan Trout and enjoyed it, but found the sauce to be burnt.
The service was great once it go late and no one else was around, but they were either understaffed, or not trained to deal with multiple tables.

Recommend this review

photo
Phone mobile review by ron-dmc (60 reviews)
March 04, 2009 - Doesn't like it - Another one of those mediocre chains. Better than Red Lobster, but not as good as the local spots like Monteray Bay or Capstone.

2 people like this review Recommend

No_photo_small
"Love it!" by Rick Thompson (3 reviews)
January 21, 2009 - Likes it - This is one of my favorite restaurants. As I read some of the negative reviews I can see why some people are having a bad experience because I have had problems with the wait staff in the past. You just need to be more assertive. If they mess something up, make them cook you a whole new meal and call the manager over and ask for a free meal. I go there at least twice weekly now and haven't had any problems what so ever in a year or so.

1 person likes this review Recommend

No_photo_small
"gross!" by cole mcnugget (4 reviews)
December 23, 2008 - Doesn't like it - if you want to sit in a cafeteria, eat at mitchells! it sound just like one, and the food is worse! yikes!!

Recommend this review

No_photo_small
"If your into bad service and cold food" by sugarcubez (2 reviews)
March 02, 2008 - Doesn't like it - I've heard so many good things about this restaurant I was excited when I finally got a chance to go.   Our server felt it more important to flirt with the hostess the entire time we were there than to actually wait on his tables.  When he did wait on the table he seemed to be making stupid teen movie moves to show off for her...  we were seated near the host stand.  The drinks were mediocre at best.  And the food was simply OK.  One dish was a shrimp and crab pasta, there was no crab, and when this was addressed the crab was replaced with COLD crab.

2 people like this review Recommend

Com-w-sm Write a review

Fans of Mitchell's Fish Market

People who like this restaurant, and how many others they like.

photo
Chris Fry
165 others
photo
MARK
153 others
No_photo_small
Mark Ioli
152 others
photo
Nikki
82 others
photo
Will
81 others
Advertise on Urbanspoon

View larger map

Driving directions

ex: 100 Main St Pittsburgh, PA

Is this your restaurant?

Add an Urbanspoon badge to your web site.
Here's an example:

271123

Nearby restaurants

See other nearby restaurants

See all Waterfront Seafood Restaurants

Nearby places



Sign in to Urbanspoon

Returning user

Email:
Password:

Forgot your password?
 

Are you on Facebook?

You can sign in to Urbanspoon with your Facebook account.

Connect with Facebook

Close

New to Urbanspoon? Sign up!

Your current email address:
Your name (optional):
Example: "John Smith". Your name will appear next to your reviews.
 
Choose a password:
Re-enter password:
 
Your picture (optional):
 
Type the text from the image above:
 
Send me the monthly Urbanspoon Pittsburgh Newsletter
 
 
Get Urbanspoon on the iPhone

Get Urbanspoon on the iPhone