Choose a city:   Buffalo    Los Angeles    New York    New York State    Pittsburgh    Rochester    Toronto      More Cities...
Urbanspoon Buffalo
photo

Add_photo

See all 2 reviews

Get our newsletter

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to get the scoop on Buffalo restaurants. See details

Home > Buffalo > Greater Buffalo > Amherst >

Is this your restaurant?

Scotch n Sirloin

(716) 837-4900

Amherst
3999 Maple Rd
Amherst, NY 14226

Send to phone

59 people have voted
V-up-big
71%
like it
Add your vote

Menu for Scotch n Sirloin

 Get Urbanspoon on your iPhone or Blackberry

User reviews of Scotch n Sirloin

Share your opinion with the world. Add your review below.

No_photo_small
"Large party" by J (3 reviews)
October 07, 2009 - Doesn't like it - So we had some friends visitng from nyc, and wanted to eat some steak. I don't know why but it was a while to wait for our large party for everything. Server, food, and check.
We ordered several steaks and pork chops but most of our orders were cooked way too well done or not cooked at all.
We sent 2 back and got them well done instead of medium.
I heard the music nights are good but i'm not too sure about the steak..

1 person likes this review Recommend

No_photo_small
"THE real steakhouse in Buffalo." by jerlew (2 reviews)
July 26, 2008 - Likes it - The Scotch N Sirloin has been around since the late 1960s.  And in the restaurant business that means that you are doing something well.  It used to be a bit more formal than it is now, recently I was there and there were peolle in jeans and casual dress.  Which goes to show that the food is the draw, not gawking at the crowd.   There are large dining rooms, that have plank floors, and the tables are spread far enough apart that you are not sitting in someone elses lap.  Each room has it's own small but well done salad bar.  With fresh baked breads, and even artichoke hearts on the salad bar.  
Dinners here are not ala carte.  Which means that you won't be paying $7.00 for a baked potato.  Or $7.00 for a plate of green beans.  Your dinner comes complete with potato and vegetable, and salad.  The top sirloin is excellent.  So are the other steaks.  The prime rib is just amazing.  Well cooked, tender and a very good portion.  And the New York Sirloin is the way a good sirloin should be.  With just the right amount of bite to it.   There are choices for Surf and Turf that would please anyone.
The best thing about the Scotch N Sirloin is that what you save on the extras you can use to get some appetizers, and have a drink in the lounge which is a wonderful bar.

Recommend this review

Com-w-sm Write a review

Bloggers, have you reviewed this restaurant? Add your review to this page.

Fans of Scotch n Sirloin

People who like this restaurant, and how many others they like.

photo prime
Ian Walpole
390 others
photo
where else would you rather be
213 others
photo prime
eating out in ny
160 others
photo
Wendell Etheridge
113 others
photo
Lara Star Martini
77 others
Advertise on Urbanspoon

View larger map

Driving directions

ex: 100 Main St Buffalo, NY

Is this your restaurant?

Add an Urbanspoon badge to your web site.
Here's an example:

461852

Nearby restaurants

See other nearby restaurants

See all Amherst Steakhouses

Nearby places



Sign in to Urbanspoon

Returning user

Email:
Password:

Forgot your password?
 

Are you on Facebook?

You can sign in to Urbanspoon with your Facebook account.

Connect with Facebook

Close

New to Urbanspoon? Sign up!

Your current email address:
Your name (optional):
Example: "John Smith". Your name will appear next to your reviews.
 
Choose a password:
Re-enter password:
 
Your picture (optional):
 
Type the text from the image above:
 
Send me the monthly Urbanspoon Buffalo Newsletter
 
 
Get Urbanspoon on the iPhone

Get Urbanspoon on the iPhone